The LinkedIn Litmus Test: Are We Hiring the Profile or the Person?
We had a candidate we knew would be a slam-dunk placement. The candidate was spot on for the role on paper, great numbers, glowing recommendations, etc., but… the client wouldn’t even speak to them.
Bad reference? Nope. Poor attitude? Not even close.
The LinkedIn profile wasn’t dynamic enough.
That’s right. Their profile didn’t have enough shine – not enough sizzle, not enough “pop.” So, pass.
Meanwhile, we’re replacing a high-level executive at another company. This individual is the walking definition of a “rockstar.” They’ve built teams, grown revenue, and flawlessly run a $100 million division. The kind of leader people rave about.
And their LinkedIn? One job. No photo. Not a single post. Just enough to prove they exist. If we were judging by profile alone, you’d think they were hiding from the internet – not leading major business units to incredible success in a very difficult market.
This is what we’re up against. We all want to hire someone we feel good about. But references? Everyone knows those are curated. Resumes? Often templated and buzzword-packed. So where do hiring managers go to get the “real story”?
LinkedIn. Or at least the illusion of it.
We’re using profile pics and summary blurbs to decide whether someone’s going to drive revenue or close deals. We’re interpreting job titles and shared articles as predictors of performance. And sometimes, we’re doing this without realizing how skewed the playing field really is.
Here’s what we mean: in sales and recruiting, a clean, confident LinkedIn profile can absolutely help. If you’re trying to sell something – a product, a service, yourself – and your profile looks like it hasn’t been updated since 2016, yeah, that might raise eyebrows.
But let’s not confuse formatting with capability.
We’ve placed quota-crushing reps with plain profiles and passed on all-star LinkedIn influencers who couldn’t sell ice in the desert. Some people write great copy. Others close great deals. Occasionally, it’s the same person – but not always.
And don’t forget: not everyone is running solo. According to a 2023 report by Sales Enablement PRO, 41% of companies now provide formal LinkedIn branding support to their sales teams. That means some of those “creative, polished” profiles you’re impressed by? Yeah – written by marketing.
What you’re really seeing isn’t personal initiative. It’s in-house PR.
Meanwhile, the rep at a smaller firm with no brand help and no Canva templates is just trying to keep up with the pipeline and maybe pick a decent headshot.
So how should you judge a profile?
Ask better questions. Does the person explain their experience clearly? Do their accomplishments feel real, not rehearsed? Does it sound like someone who gets your industry and your customers? Is there anything here that makes you want to talk to them?
That’s the point. A LinkedIn profile should open the door. It should start a conversation – not end one.
If you’re a candidate, especially in sales or recruiting, yes – give your profile some love. Add a headline that sounds like a human. Update your experience. Ditch the selfie from your cousin’s wedding and put something on there that says, “I’m a pro.” You don’t have to post every week or become a thought leader, but you do need to show up.
Because whether it’s fair or not, people are looking. And if the only thing standing between you and the offer is a half-finished profile, that’s a loss you don’t need.
Here’s the reality: Some of the best people don’t “look” great on LinkedIn. And some of the best-looking profiles are more smoke than substance. You want to hire someone who can do the job – not just sell the image of someone who can.
So before you swipe left on a profile, ask yourself: Are you hiring a professional? Or are you just hiring a profile?
Contact Us
We would love to hear from you!